100+ Non Candy Plastic Easter Egg Stuffers Ideas

Looking for some candy free Easter basket ideas? Get creative with your Easter baskets with these non candy plastic Easter egg stuffers ideas that kids will love! Includes Easter ideas for babies, toddlers, kids, tweens, teens and even adults along with where to find plastic Easter eggs in a variety of sizes!

My kids love candy. We’ve never been a sugar free home but between Halloween, Christmas and Valentine’s Day candy by the time Easter rolls around I’m usually ready to go candy free or at the very least “less candy” for Easter.

Even as my kids get older, they still love a good Easter egg hunt! We have bags and bags of plastic Easter eggs in a variety of sizes that we store away for Easter and I’m always on the lookout for fun things to put inside of them!

I originally wrote this post when my daughter was a toddler. We were getting ready to potty train her and I decided to stuff her plastic Easter eggs with “big girl panties” and other trinkets I knew she would love.

A few years later when my son was at the potty training age we repeated the tradition by stuffing his plastic Easter eggs with “big boy underwear”.

Ever since then the tradition of finding fun things to put in Easter Eggs besides candy has continued.

Chocolate Easter bunnies are great, but I thought I would share some of my favorites non-candy Easter egg fillers for other parents looking to do the same thing!

Where To Find Plastic Easter Eggs

Plastic Easter Eggs can be found at a variety of places from the Dollar store, to big box stores like Walmart and Target to Amazon.

My number 1 suggestion for when you are buying plastic Easter eggs is to look for a variety of sizes.

Here are some size ideas for plastic eggs for you!

Easter Egg Stuffers For Babies

Babies may not remember there very first Easter, but that doesn’t mean they shouldn’t join in on the Easter fun! Here are some adorable Easter egg stuffer ideas for babies!

25 More Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas For Babies:

• Soft teething toys
• Rattles
• Miniature board books
• Bath toys
• Small plush toys
• Pacifiers
• Baby spoons
• Finger puppets
• Miniature stuffed animals
• Socks with cute designs
• Baby hats
• Small soft blocks
• Baby board books with bright colors
• Rubber ducks
• Miniature baby dolls
• Stacking cups
• Teething rings
• Small musical toys
• Miniature vehicles
• Crinkly toys
• Baby-safe mirrors
• Play keys
• Sensory balls
• Baby sunglasses
• Finger paint
• Play food toys

Easter Egg Stuffers For Toddlers

There is nothing like experiencing the magic of different holidays through the eyes of toddlers! Each Easter egg opened is sure to bring surprise and delight to your little one! Here are my favorite Easter egg stuffer ideas for toddlers!

30 More Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas For Toddlers:

• Finger puppets
• Stickers
• Miniature stuffed animals
• Small board books
• Play-Doh / Play Dough
• Small plastic animals
• Bubble solution
• Bath toys
• Sippy cup or water bottle with cute design
• Snack cups
• Miniature puzzles with large pieces
• Miniature cars or trucks
• Silly straws
• Miniature musical instruments
• Toy keys
• Miniature rubber ducks
• Bath crayons
• Soft foam balls
• Plastic building blocks
• Crayons
• Finger crayons
• Wind-up toys
• Flashcards
• Wooden blocks
• Colorful shoelaces
• Miniature tea set
• Plastic gardening tools
• Small magnifying glass
• Small toy phone
• Miniature doctor kit
• Underwear
• Novelty Socks

Easter Egg Stuffers For Kids

Be ready cheers of delight when your kiddos finish their Easter egg hunt and open up their Easter eggs! These ideas are so much fun and kids will love them!

30 More Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas For Kids:

• Stickers
• Legos
• Money and coins
• Temporary tattoos
• Miniature figurines
• Hair accessories
• Toy cars
• Keychains
• Erasers
• Bouncy balls
• Finger puppets
• Silly Putty
• Miniature puzzles
• Small stuffed animals
• Miniature notebooks
• Bracelets
• Necklaces
• Finger rings
• Marbles
• Miniature rubber ducks
• Miniature plastic dinosaurs and other small toys
• Slime
• Play-Doh
• Miniature games
• Glow-in-the-dark stars
• Foam airplanes
• Fidget spinners
• Small building blocks
• Miniature musical instruments
• Watercolor paints
• Colored pencils
• Crayons
• Underwear
• Novelty socks
• Rubber Stamps
• Beads and bracelet making supplies
• Balloons
• Flower seeds

Easter Egg Stuffers For Tweens

30 More Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas For Tweens:

• Movie Tickets
• Miniature figurines or action figures
• Small puzzle toys
• Stickers or temporary tattoos
• Silly putty or slime
• Miniature portable speakers
• Small plush toys or stuffed animals
• Keychains
• Hair accessories, like scrunchies or hair clips
• Gum or breath mints
• Miniature board games
• Scented markers or crayons
• Small notebooks or journals
• Miniature card games like Uno or Go Fish
• Personalized water bottles or tumblers
• Fun-shaped erasers or pencil toppers
• Friendship bracelets or jewelry-making kits
• Pop sockets or phone rings
• Miniature succulent plants
• Decorative shoelaces or shoe charms
• Play-Doh or modeling clay
• Miniature flashlights
• Lip balm or chapstick
• Small hand-held mirrors
• Pocket-sized notebooks or journals
• Whistles or noisemakers
• Travel-sized games like chess or checkers
• Personalized keychains or luggage tags
• Decorative socks
• Art supplies, like colored pencils or paintbrushes
• Hand-held fans or mini hand sanitizers
• Novelty Socks
• Hair ties

Easter Egg Stuffers For Teens

30 More Easter Basket Stuffer Ideas For Teens:

• Miniature action figures
• Small puzzle toys
• Emoji stress balls
• Movie Tickets
• Earbuds or headphones
• Miniature portable chargers
• Keychains
• Scented candles
• Fidget spinners
• Small makeup items, like lip balm or nail polish
• Gum or breath mints
• Personalized phone cases or phone grips
• Small notebooks or journals
• Temporary tattoos or stickers
• Hair accessories, like scrunchies or hair clips
• Funky socks
• Miniature board games
• Travel-sized games like Uno or Scrabble
• Pop sockets or phone rings
• Miniature succulent plants
• Small plush toys or stuffed animals
• Pens, pencils or highlighters
• Small hand-held mirrors
• Pocket-sized notebooks or journals
• Decorative sticky notes or bookmarks
• Small hand-held fans
• Personalized keychains or luggage tags
• Art supplies, like colored pencils or paintbrushes
• Miniature flashlights
• Lip balm or chapstick
• Fun magnets
• Activity coupons

Bonus Easter Egg Stuffer Ideas For Adults

Easter isn’t just for kids! Here are few bonus ideas of Easter basket stuffers that adults will like too!

More Fun Easter Ideas

I hope you loved these Easter egg filler ideas! If you are looking for more Easter Craft and Recipe ideas? I’ve got a ton of them on Hello Creative Family! Here are some that I think you might like!